On a few exemplary papers from a fun semester of contemporary analysis.
As I wrote at length in this
semester preview post, I used a new syllabus for my Writing II course this
spring, one analyzing our 21st century world and identities from a
variety of angles. It worked really well, I’d say, and that can be concisely
illustrated with an exemplary paper for each of the three relevant assignments
(the fourth, a research paper, was more individually driven and less necessarily
tied to the course content):
1)
Ad Analysis: For the
first major assignment, the students chose an advertisement (in any medium) and
both read it closely and put it in context of some other text or issue. In one
of the best papers in the batch, a student worked with an interestingly progressive
new Swiffer ad, one that portrays 21st century families in a variety
of ways (including an amputee husband who does the majority of his family’s
cleaning); he then contextualized it with a far more traditional, original Swiffer ad,
developing compelling readings of gender, family, and society as a result.
2)
21st Century
Identities: For the second major assignment (revised and extended into another
paper as well), the students considered both digital and off-line identities
and issues, engaging with their own personal narratives as well as analytical
lenses. One of my students, a second generation Arab American woman, wrote an
incredibly nuanced and thoughtful paper on technology, media, and gender and
identity in both Middle Eastern and American contexts, managing in just a few
short pages to resist stereotyped or simplistic engagements with either
cultural context. To say I learned a lot from her work would be an
understatement.
3)
Comparative Film/TV
Analysis: For the third major assignment, the students chose a visual text
(either a film or episode of a TV show) and developed extended analyses, both
focused on the one text and comparing it to a second such text. In one of the
more original papers I’ve ever read, a student utilized an article we’d read on
recent TV anti-heroes and compared the protagonist of the film American Beauty with
more overt anti-heroes such as Dexter Morgan and Frank
Underwood, arguing that the film’s seemingly heroic protagonist is actually
more amoral and anti-heroic than the TV types. He changed my whole perspective
on both the original film and the TV trope, and, like the class as a whole,
made me think about our 21st century moment in the process.
Next recap tomorrow,
Ben
PS. How was your spring semester?
No comments:
Post a Comment