[Inspired both
by the recent events I’ll include in Monday’s and Tuesday’s posts and the
historical anniversary on which I’ll focus in Friday’s, a series
AmericanStudying epidemics, past and present.]
On how an
anniversary helps us remember an iconic and complex figure.
One hundred
years ago today, on March 27th, 1915, Mary Mallon (1869-1938)—better known
as “Typhoid Mary”—was quarantined by public health officials for the second
and final time. The Irish
immigrant and cook had previously infected numerous New York-area employers,
families, and communities with the highly contagious and dangerous typhoid
fever; the incidents began around 1900, but it was not until a 1906 outbreak
in Oyster Bay that Mary’s role in them was discovered, and she was
quarantined from 1907 to 1910 in a clinic on North
Brother Island. Upon her release she agreed to change professions, but
instead changed her name and began working as a cook once more. Arrested in
1915 after starting yet
another typhoid outbreak, this one at New York’s Sloane Hospital for Women,
Mary was taken once again to North Brother Island, where she would remain in
quarantine for the final twenty-three years of her life.
Typhoid Mary’s
striking story can be contexualized in a number of AmericanStudies ways. The
public fascination with her (she was interviewed
numerous times during those final decades of quarantine) reflects our longstanding interest in “true
crime” narratives and figures, in seeking to understand and perhaps even
empathize with those who do horrific
or sociopathic things to their fellow citizens. At the same time, but on
the other end of the emotive spectrum, the fearful and paranoid responses to
Mary (and it is possible to see those responses as extreme at the same time
that we recognize her culpability in her arc) were undoubtedly connected to
equally longstanding
narratives of dirty and diseased immigrants and the threats they pose to
our communities and culture: narratives that had long been associated specifically
with Irish immigrants; and that in response to the late 19th and
early 20th century waves of arrivals from Southern and Eastern
Europe, Southeast Asia, and Latin America were newly
energized in this period. In both these ways, the Mary of North Brother
Island—quarantined away from the rest of America and yet forever available for interviews
and pictures—could be said to represent a twisted American ideal.
Comparing Mary’s
life and history to a more genuinely idealized American story offers another
lens through which to analyze her, however. As part of a September
2013 series on Newport’s The Breakers, I wrote a
post on Rudy Stanish, the son of Eastern Europe immigrants who would rise
to become the “Omelet King,” one of the most famous chefs in American history. Stanish’s
Newport experiences began in 1929, while Mary was still alive and quarantined;
in that, and even more in their shared profession, social status (as servants
of wealthy families), and immigrant background, the two offer a compelling and complex
comparison. Each life and identity is individual and shouldn’t be reduced to
types or mythic narratives, but it’s hard for me to resist noting that Rudy and
Mary represent two sides to the same coin, the American
Dream and American
Nightmare respectively. Their versions are extremes, of course—few Americans
end up in either lifelong quarantine or as a chef to the stars—but that doesn’t
mean they can’t be connected to more typical communal experiences. And it’s
fair—if more pessimistic than I like to be—to say that more Americans
experience the nightmare than the dream; and thus to note that we might understand
how such a nightmare might lead to the life and choices of a woman like Typhoid
Mary.
March Recap this
weekend,
Ben
PS. What do you
think?
No comments:
Post a Comment